That was not a Super Bowl-contending team on the field at Candlestick today. Going into the fourth quarter, the only thing separating the 49ers from the mediocre (at best) Dolphins was a fumbled punt return.
The offense is missing a key ingredient since Colin Kapernick took over:
consistency. Yes, there are some flashes of brilliance with big plays like the 50-yard scamper into the endzone to put the game (finally) out of reach today. But there are still too many instances where the offense sputters for several drives in a row, allowing inferior opponents to remain in (or even win) the game.
And before anybody starts talking about the awesome throw CK made to Randy Moss that should have resulted in a touchdown (nice to see Mike Carrey's crew still stinks and misses obvious pass interference penalties), keep in mind that it's STILL an excuse.
Everybody WANTS Kaepernick to succeed. I do, too. Whatever gets the 49ers their sixth ring is totally fine with me. But giving this inconsistent offense the benefit of the doubt by making excuses doesn't fly in December, and it sure is hell won't help matters in January. Win
now. Get your sh*t together. Because as far as I can tell, things were running much more smoothly with #11 behind center.
For whatever reason, the coaching staff still doesn't know what to do with this new offense. Too many "cute" plays. Too many ineffective running calls in long-yardage situations. For the second week in a row, too many conservative plays when they should be aggressive, and being too aggressive (like passing twice before going three-and-out when trying to burn the clock late in the fourth quarter after Miami pulled to within seven points) when they should have been conservative.
I'm not championing Alex Smith, but I do know if he put up the same numbers over the past four weeks that Kaepernick has, everybody would still be calling him nothing more than a game manager. "Would Alex Smith be able to run for that last touchdown today?" No (
although the Saints might have a different opinion). But the team wouldn't be burning most of their timeouts in each half because the ball wasn't getting snapped before the gameclock expired, either.
Through week Week 10, there was a rhythm. A process. Certain expectations. That's gone, now. Blame Kapernick, blame the coaches, blame the players' biorhythms, blame the goddamned seagulls flying around Candlestick Park. I don't care. Things have to get better - and soon - if the 49ers want to meet their goal of playing in the Super Bowl.
The defense, while generally very, very good, continues to make too many penalties while giving up long drives during crucial points in the game. A championship defense should NEVER allow an ineffective offense like Miami's to march 80 yards midway through the fourth quarter to make it a one-score game. That's when the defense should have killed the Dolphins' hopes with a three-and-out or a turnover.
About midway through today's contest, if you didn't know the 49ers were currently holding the second seed in the NFC, you'd think you were watching a couple of 3-9 teams struggle to finish their seasons. It was ugly, and reminiscent of all of those pathetic games we watched during the Erickson, Nolan and Singletary eras, right down to the wasted timeouts and mental/communication errors.
So, is it all
Doom and Gloom? No. But with a Sunday-night matchup in New England and a crucial divisional game against the surging Seahawks looming ahead over the next couple of weeks, there is no margin for error. The 49ers need to start playing like the champions they want to be.
Now.